11 July 2011

Lost and Forgotten Cattle Trails:

Old roads fascinate me.  I find the visual evidence of our forebearers' passing mysterious, particularly if the path is no longer in use.

Wagon tracks carved into rocks along old Chisholm Trail near Brushy Creek, Texas.

The oldest cattle trails of the American West began in Texas, traveled through Indian Territory (later Oklahoma) and ended in Missouri.  Later trails, such as the Chisholm Trail, became popular after the Civil War, and traveled more westerly routes to Kansas.

Wagon ruts along old Chisholm Trail near Brush Creek, Texas.

The Old Shawnee Trail has had many names since the first droves meandered northeast on it in the 1830s.  Because it passed near a Shawnee village, that name stuck.  Branching off from it are other trails, including the lesser known West Shawnee Trail.  While fairly well-known in Texas due to the efforts of preservationists and local historians, not much is known about the route in Oklahoma.  Certainly it is unmarked, and seems to be relegated to brief passages in old history books.

I became interested in this particular trail because it travels through Lincoln County, Oklahoma, where my father owns a ranch.    I wanted to see if anything remains to the present day near the place where it passes only 13 miles away from Dad's place:  Stroud, OK. 

As is usual for me, I studied some old maps first.  According to the late 19th century sources (admittedly out-of-date for this early 19th century trail), it passed over the Deep Fork of the Canadian River around the Sac and Fox Agency in Indian Territory.

I noticed that even though the trail was largely out of use by cattle in the 1880s, the trails are still marked on the maps.
This indicates to me that by this point, the trails are being used for other purposes.  A path used for this long is far more likely to have remnants visible today.  I decided to check a 20th century map.

1932 USGS Stroud, OK     Map features red and white “well traveled road” heading North across Deep Fork River
This "well traveled road" followed more or less the same path as the West Shawnee Trail, even crossing the river near the same location.  In 1932, that would make the West Shawnee Trail approximately one hundred years old!  Still, does the trail exist today?  I turned to Google Maps and was only slightly disappointed.  

2011 Map of Deep Fork River bend, approximately 4 miles south of Stroud, Oklahoma (Google).  “Well traveled road” follows extant streets until meeting the river.
I added the red dashed line to help those unfamiliar with the area see where the old trail went.  The extant streets today stop short of the river on both sides.  However, this is a rural area, and the old fords wouldn't be marked on a 2011 Google Map.  Fortunately, Bing provides me with an aerial view, though the view in this area hasn't been updated/improved recently.

2011 Bing Map view of Deep Fork River bend approximately 4 miles south of Stroud.  View highlighted of probable crossing of one branch of the West Shawnee Cattle Trail.  Looks like the trail is still there!  (Thanks, Justin, for the suggestion of Bing.)

I have yet to actually travel to this area to take some photographs, but probably will within the next few months.  I'll be looking for any wagon ruts or depressions in this area indicating the exact path of travel.  While the red box marks the "well traveled road" seen in the 1932 map, I must point out that rivers are always altering course, and the cattle probably forded the river at several different locations along this bend through the years, depending upon the season/currents/shifting banks.  Spots to the east of the red box are also highly likely locations of crossing.

I queried a prominent Amerindian historian in our area (my mother-in-law), Dr. Mary Jane Warde, and she checked with her Osage friends before emailing back:  
"Another friend, Louis Burns, discusses it in his History of the Osage People. He is 91, a sweetheart and an Osage elder who grew up cowboying in Osage County and went on to be a geography professor. He and one of his grandfathers traveled the old Osage trails in a Model T noting the routes and camping places, what the names are and why. He says the West Shawnee Trail followed an old Osage trail, and you can usually trace their routes because they always went along the valleys on the left hand side of a creek or river with the current at your back."

If this is true, portions of the West Shawnee Trail are hundreds of years old - certainly something worth remembering and marking in our relatively new state!  While I find it frustrating that Oklahoma has failed to preserve some of its most interesting pre-statehood history, I also recognize the opportunity to investigate some history on my own, which is both enjoyable and rewarding. I know I'm not the only historian who would like Oklahoma's sections of the Old Shawnee Trail to land on the National Register of Historic Places.