27 January 2012

Why Are Today's Women Unhappy?

According to a recent study, women today are less happy than they were 40 years ago, and are less happy than men. 
Official Happiness Meter, courtesy of the Carebears.


This study by "economists Betsey Stevenson and Justin Wolfers... indicates that across race, marriage status, economic bracket, and even country, women's subjective experience of being happy has declined both absolutely and in relation to men."

Putting aside the fact that economists decided this, and not someone who is actually trained in handling human emotion, this is sobering news.  With all our liberation and freedom, how can the happiness levels of women be less than in the 1960s?  

And what do men have to be so happy about?
Fair enough.

Religious folks will tell you that all this liberation has taken women away from our purpose in life, which is to care for the home and hearth while the man is at work.  We should have a couple of babies (more than a couple, if you're Catholic or Baptist), and work hard to raise them.  This is what Nature and God intended.  To deviate from this path is to bring about our own unhappiness.


In a New York Times editorial about this same study, the conclusion was a bit different.

"There's no necessary reason why feminists and cultural conservatives can't join forces -- in the same way that they made common cause during the pornography wars of the 1980s -- behind a social revolution that ostracizes serial baby-daddies and trophy-wife collectors as thoroughly as the 'fallen women' of a more patriarchal age."

He suggests that it is in fact the fault of Men that Women are so unhappy.  Think about it - men made out like bandits in this age of sexual liberation!  Want regular, socially acceptable sex?  Don't get married; just get your girlfriend to move in with you.  Bored with your 40 year old wife/mother of your children?  Trade her for two twenty-year-olds.  Knock a girl up?  Don't marry her, and don't worry about the baby's life complicating your own.  After all, the best form of birth control is not using your real name. 


 
Yet as much fun as it is to blame men for all female ills, I just can't agree in this instance.  Yes, there are men out there who are jerks.  To suggest that all women are less happy today because of a few bums is unfair to men.  This view is also unfair to women, as it implies that our happiness is dependent upon men (when my happiness is obviously dependent upon shoes).



Personally, I believe that our unhappiness is self-imposed. 

For the most part, American women tend to believe that they must do the following in order to be considered a complete and successful woman:
 

  • I HAVE to get married.
  • I HAVE to have a career.
  • I HAVE to have children.
  • I HAVE to look good while doing it (exercise, eat well, wear the right clothing, keep a nice house).

But it's more than merely what I think about myself.  If any woman is lacking in any of the aforementioned departments, then all the other hens sit in judgment. 

"Sally and her husband haven't had kids yet.  Do you think there's something wrong with her?"

"Omg, Julie has 3 little girls, and all she does is work.  What kind of mother leaves her kids at day care for someone else to raise?"

"Honey, you're almost 35 and you're still not married.  Are you at least seeing anyone? There's this nice man from church that I want you to meet..."


Supposedly, modern females in this country have "choices."  However, I noticed we tend to place limitations and expectations on each other without any help from men.  I can't tell you how many times I've been told how selfish I am because I don't want kids, or how I'll "change my mind in time."  I thought Woman's Rights and the Pill allowed me to have reproductive freedom.  
I guess not. 

What about women who actually want to be housewives? Some women are perfectly happy to care for the home and for their children while their husband works.  "Progressives" will say that those women live under a misogynistic husband, have been socialized to think this is their correct path, and are too weak to stand up for themselves. 




"Choice" to some feminists means "Choice as long as you do what I think you should do."  

Women are judged by other women for having children and keeping the career, for not having a career and staying home, for not having children.... the list goes on.

This is why we're unhappy.  It is our own fault.

19 comments:

  1. I'm going with the pie explanation. Yup, modern women would be happier if men made them more pies.

    ReplyDelete
  2. "if by "happy" you mean trapped with no means of escape...then yes, I'm happy." (Love that one!)
    But yes, pies would help; if the men also cleaned up the kitchen after.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Women are unhappy because they're trying to be men.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I participated in a month-long happiness survey in which an outfit sent me mobile alerts, I'd pop onto their website, answer a few questions about what I was doing, what was on my mind, and how happy I (thought I) was. The survey results were interesting. I was only moderately happy dealing with children and friends, and most happy when running or reading a book. (Other surveys have showed that grandparents are happier dealing with kids than parents are.)

    We should all run. And read books. Screw the kids.

    ReplyDelete
  5. P.S. I am not a woman. My comments necessarily reflect the male perspective.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I wonder if it's more a matter of paying too much attention to media (social or otherwise).
    People on TV and Facebook look really happy. I'm not as happy as they are. Therefore, I must not be very happy at all.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I would like to amend that to include men who aren't eating their fair share of pie. At least, not often enough, according to Rooney Mara.

    ReplyDelete
  8. No...I have been discussing this at work...women are completely responsible..we are fed this crap of WHAT will make us happy. I personally stay clear of most women in general..I find them to be much more insecure..and that's dangerous. Men are much more secure with what they want. Now, with that said I have 3 kids. I come home from work and drive whoever to whatever practice as now kids play sports year round..the over productive schedules that women have to mold their lives around is what is leaving women unhappy. For example...I worked till 3.. went to one kids volleyball game...came home...put on running stuff...to only discover I have to get bk in car and take other to soccer practice...until 9pm tomorrow...rinse..shampoo..and repeat...this is what makes women unhappy...stop..drop..and go.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for taking a moment to post from a mother's perspective. You appear to be constantly on the go, which does nothing positive for one's stress level, which in turn affects health - both of which affect happiness.
      I hope you get a well-deserved vacation soon!

      Delete
  9. Thanks for letting me vent! I have been just fried all week...I know I'm not alone but some are so scared of saying " this sucks!!!"...yes sometimes its what you have to do, but finding folks you can be honest with is so helpful. My husband doesnt get it as his Mom never complained...more of a martyr...he's a firefighter so he works long shifts which means I come home from work at 3 and usually dont see my house until 9....every once In a while you gotta blow...I have 3 great kids...one is at a college showcase soccer tourn this week...its her thing....I hold the title of Anti Soccer Select Mom for a reason....I know there are others like me...I've got It good, but If I could go without sleep I'd be thrilled...more time to relax.....sports..school..Its all different now. No more going to practice after school now its driving to different lands far away...whole thing Is draining..Happy Thanksgiving all:)

    ReplyDelete
  10. Wemon are unhappy, because they say they are unhappy to them selves and eachother. So they become unhappy. You are what you think everyday and then you want the family friends to feel like you.
    That why girls get along with other men not girls.

    ReplyDelete
  11. It is miserable to be a woman. Hormones menopause birth control face creams makeup tampons wrinkles getting oldest fast wemon don't have friends they hate eachother. When one is happy the other is upset she is happy and makes the her unhappy.If there was a world war started by wemon it would still be war times now. I am sorry for you wemon. 80% of devorses are initiated by wemon that might as well be 100%. I am 37 years old I have seen you wemon in action. You are all crazy.

    ReplyDelete
  12. And don't change one thing about your selves girls bcause it makes us guys happy.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I'm going to sound very sexist when I say this, but I'm not trying to be. I have Sirius and after spending the last couple years listening to Cosmo Radio, I've come to the conclusion that modern women's culture (women's magazines, TV shows, movies, etc.) is entirely built on the idea that you're not happy unless you're x, and x is whatever it is the company behind the product wants.

    I'll try to unconfuse it: Women take-to-heart much more the messages of media then men do. One of the hosts suggested putting "Warning: This is Not How Real Life Relationships Work" on Nicholas Sparks' books. The general message of media, especially advertising, and products like clothes is "You are inferior if you do not buy our product". I think a lot more women internalize that as truth then men do.

    If your relationship isn't as dramatic as TV/Movies, you're doing it wrong. If you don't dress like Heidi Klum, you're doing it wrong. If your SO is not buying you a car for Christmas, he's doing it wrong and you're doing it wrong by still being with him.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. One of the hosts suggested putting "Warning: This is Not How Real Life Relationships Work" on Nicholas Sparks' books.

      This is hilarious and (sadly) accurate. This warning should also be affixed to Twilight books.

      Delete
  14. Hello

    I think that a women's desire to have children is inborn. I also believe that trying to be a man when your not does not work. Feminazism does not work.
    It's going to be hard to put the shit back in the horse.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. *woman's
      *you're
      "Feminazism" is not a word. Drug-addicts on the radio may fabricate words, but that doesn't mean the rest of us have to pay attention to them.

      Not all women want to have children. Not all women can have children. Not having children doesn't mean that I am therefore attempting to be a man. Women (usually poor women) throughout history have had jobs. This is not new, and doesn't indicate they are trying to be men.

      I've decided to discard your opinion for two reasons:
      1) You offered no evidence to back up your statement.
      2) Your failure to grasp basic English causes me to question your critical thinking abilities. If, however, your first language isn't English, then I'll revisit this comment.

      Delete
  15. "How Women Gained Power by Mass-Murder of Husbands." This article explains everything!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Very good article.

    I'd say most everyone is less happy these days, and not just women. We live in a world full of mixed signals, contradictions, and hypocrisies; and all the while we're the all of us told that wealth will make us happy.

    ReplyDelete